66 

don’t call it a shitstorm

April 22nd, 2010

Sometimes, at Errol HQ, we have to do unpleasant things. Well, not really. Usually we just make the interns do all the stuff we don’t enjoy, like stacking the dishwasher, fending off bill-collectors with sharp sticks and fetching us vats of Diet Coke when we are sleepy or hungover.

But today we have to talk about … the Storm. Oh man, we haven’t been this distressed/surprised/overwhelmed/confused since Britney got the crack itch and shaved off all her hair.

First things first: YES WE TOLD YOU THEY WERE EVIL. We tipped you all off aaages ago that the Storm, aka Globo Gym, were inherently untrustworthy and potentially the enemy of all that is good and lovely in this world.

But even we didn’t think things were this dramatic. $1.7 million in shifty salary cap breaches over five years. <insert Phil Gould WOW here>

We spent the afternoon huddled around watching the live press conference from the NRL – Intern John John even put on his serious hotpants (they’re pin-striped) – and we couldn’t decide whether we were more:

a) shocked by how harsh the penalty ended up being;

b) shocked at how insane the salary cap breaches were;

c) outraged that the penalty didn’t include taking the 2009 wooden spoon away from the Roosters (that was just Sassy);

d) just really really upset for David Gallop. Our fave sporting administrator looked truly devastated. We were both actually close to tears. We know DG enough to know he is an awesome bloke and he does NOT deserve this fuckery.

When Greg Inglis got in trouble with the law, we sent him comical chocolate-covered fruit flowers to cheer him up, but there aren’t enough fruit flowers in the world for this, for serious. NOT ENOUGH FRUIT FLOWERS IN THE WORLD.

Anyway. Here are some of our educated thoughtz on this.

OF COURSE IT WAS AFL

We could not be less surprised that people are suggesting Brian Waldron masterminded this. Of course he did. If there is one unarguable truth about rugby league, it’s that scandals always come out, and no one keeps any secrets. They are physically incapable of doing this. Sure, league players and managers and administrators can be shifty sometimes, but not to this extent, with this level of deceit, this successfully, and in this organised a fashion. As a rule, Rugby League is nothing but transparent, honest and a little bit … let’s just call it “un-slick”. It’s part of why we love it so much.

BUT WHAT ABOUT BILLY?

Whenever we get onto the topic of whether the players knew what is up, Sassy just stops and says two words: Jamal. Idris.

That’s right, remember when Jamal admitted that he didn’t know he had to pay tax? Our feeling is that you should never underestimate how clueless people can be. And be ‘people’ we mean ‘footy players, or Errol girls’. We do some really, really ridiculously dumb stuff sometimes.

Like John Kite taking his passport to the airport for a flight to Queensland. Or the time Sassy got out the wrong side of a cab in New York and the door got ripped off. Until we find out that the players were collecting giant sacks of cash from the locker room every Friday or something, we’re willing to think maybe not all the players knew.

We have a semi-insider’s view on what goes on in footy and we know that the game runs on gossip. But we are unsure if players openly talk about their salary with other players.

It’s entirely possible at least SOME of the Storm players knew, or had an inkling, of what was going on. But after watching the bloopers video from the making of the Indigenous All-Stars ad, can you really say you think Greg Inglis is right on top of his finances? Really?

We imagine when he rocks up to his accountant and his manager asks about his receipts he just answers “… what?”

THANKS, BIN LADEN

Why yes, we did just quote The Hangover! Thanks for noticing. Turns out this whole Melbourne shitstorm will screw everyone over. There’ll be no more masturbating on planes for anyone. As in, there’ll be no happy ending to this story (GET IT? HAPPY ENDING? It’s funny cause it means … you know).

For the record, we agree with the NRL’s plan of punishment. In fact it’s kind of delightfully diabolical the way they are forcing the club to go through the motions for the rest of the year with no pot of gold at the end of the rainbow. It’s very Bond villain don’t you think?

But let’s be serious for a minute.

If the Melbourne Storm loses all their premiership points earned so far for the 2010 season, but keeps going, then they effectively keep cheating because they already have a team that breaches the salary cap. Hello unfair.

If they keep going the way the NRL wants them to – with no points, and not winning any more points – then every other team has to risk injury and suspension playing a team that has no chance of winning the premiership anyway. The games are dead rubbers, crowds are lower, and everyone including the sponsors is sadpants. After all, how well can the Storm play when they’re not playing for anything? Maybe they will play on emotion for the next few weeks, but how will they be feeling come round 20?

And if the Storm don’t play at all, that’s one game less per round. Teams would miss out on match experience and momentum, and the sponsors would be super sadpants.

And whichever ones happens, Storm fans – all ten of them – get nothing. We’re pretty happy for something bad to happen to that douchebag Melbourne fan with the cowbell, cause that is fucking IRRITATING, but we do feel truly awful for the rest of the Storm kids.

As much as we have always loathed the Storm, we want the club to survive. Because if nothing else, it’s providing an alternative to the horrendousness that is AFL, and that’s bloody important.

THOUGHTS PEOPLE. TELL US EVERYTHING YOU THINK.

  • sassy

    I think the fairest option, theoretically, would be to take the Storm’s points from the first six rounds, but then give them the opportunity to sack and payout players to get back under the salary cap and keep playing for points from then on. except that there’s no way the Storm could turn that around and organise it quickly enough to get back on the field and play for anything, you know? in practical terms it’s impossible.

    so I think the NRL’s logic is that if they can’t play for points, it’s better to have them play for nothing than to cancel the games altogether. at least then they have a hope of getting SOME revenue from the games and honouring the other team’s sponsorship agreements.

    it’s unfair that the other teams have to play a non-competing Storm now, but it would also be unfair to all the other teams if they had to have bye weeks instead and lose their momentum.

  • Philo

    So, all the pieces of the puzzle fall into place – the star lineup, the ability to retain them, scooping up Brett Finch just-like-that, the sad face playing and Cameron Smith’s kicking last Monday,etc etc

    The Storm has never been the right fit for NRL because a) they are a franchise of News Ltd, not a club in the normal sense of a rugby league club, b) they were established for the sole reason of boosting News Ltd TV ratings in Melbourne in order to make Rupert richer, c) the club is a child of Super League’s failure to take over our game completely,and d) there have no local feeder clubs, no junior comps, and until recently no under-20s.

    In other words, they are a product, not a team. Like the NFL.

    Plus partisan hate: they won their 1st (and now only) grand final in 1999 against the flow of the game off a forward pass, a professional foul, and the joke of a penalty try.

    A club with no history now has no future. Business is business. Just desserts.

    No tears here.

  • Hazy

    Everyone keeps saying now they know why we had stars. They weren’t stars when they came to the storm. No one wanted them… the systems in place there through the coach etc made them who they are, now other teams get the rewards.

    Also wasn’t the cowboys wholly owned by News ltd at some point too?

    The Essendon V Collingwood game with have 100,000 people there this weekend, when , apart from GF’s has the NRL ever had a match like that? and you know what, they never will as long as they keep up the anti melbourne anti non nsw/qld feelings …

  • alieshaR

    Bahahah his face makes it all okay, my all time favourite part of that vid HEART

  • louiiseee

    Great post as always girls!

    Today at school I had so many people asking me about what happened (is it weird I’ve earned a reputation as an nrl go-to girl at my school?) and mostly it was about the salary cap. I’m just wondering, what exactly falls under the salary cap? So the players’ salaries (no duh) but I remember reading something about FuiFui’s family’s flights & scott prince’s house etc so i am absolutely confuzzled about what is included :S
    Just as an example, because Billy Slater does advertisements for suzuki or whatevz, does the money he earns for that fall under the cap?
    Sorry don’t know if that question is relevant to the current situation and it probably isn’t worded that well but a lot of people, present company included, were wondering.

    I really feel for the handful of melbourne storm members. I would be absolutely ropable if I were them and be sticking my hand out for my money back.

    Once again, really impressed with the post :)

  • Dave

    Everything rugby League that News Ltd touches goes to poo. The quicker they are kicked out of our game the better.

  • Oliva

    What an absolute ballsup!
    The decision to kill off Melbourne for the 2010 season is probably the dumbest of a bagful of dumb decisions that the NRL Administration has made. One often hears stories about how thick rugby league people are. I used to think it’s just idle gossip. But, after a while it sure looks that way.
    I would stick the blame fair and square where it belongs. NRL has a salary cap system that does not work. The clubs are pressured to pay marque players decent money to keep them. There’s a conflict there and the NRL hasn’t got the brains to work it out. The salary cap has always been a huge bone of contention. All Clubs have salary cap issues but not all will get the big forensic investigation because they are well connected.
    Why do you think the comp is being flooded with good young Kiwi players. It’s because they are dirt cheap. They loosen up the salary cap so the likes of Billy and Smithy and Ellis can get the fat paychecks that they [their managers] demand.
    The reason given for the cap is that it evens up the competition.
    Frankly I don’t think that’s a reason I think it’s just an excuse.
    Even so my sympathies are with the Melbourne grass-roots, the fans. They are the big losers. The players and administrators can trip off to other Clubs without a backward glance but the fans will be in mourning forever.

  • mags

    POP QUIZ

    Who cried because she was thinking about the poor players and the poor die-hard fans who are being punished for doing nothing wrong?

    This girl

    Who wants to meet the people that did this to the club, the players, the fans and the game and spit in their faces and then scream non-stop for about five minutes?

    This girl

  • http://www.twitter.com/captainsuburbia Evan

    Here I go: I’m one of those (apparently) ultra-rare thingies called Melbourne Storm members. The last few days have been a mixture of sadness and annoyance, but mostly anger at the small group of farkwits that completely farked us over.

    Yeah, of course we paid the team we assembled more than we allowed to. Yeah they might’ve been a bunch of rejects from other clubs but that doesn’t really make a rats arse of a difference now.

    I have no intention of doing something so pointless as handing back my membership. Provided the appropriate people are sent to work in salt mines I’m more than happy to keep giving the team my financial support.

    I really really hope that players & Bellamy weren’t in on it. A lot of people are saying that’s a totally unrealistic hope, but come on – if it were your club you’d be hoping too even for the tiniest smidgiest saving grace. There was a really interesting interview with Mark Geyer re payments and such on the ABC’s AM program this morning, the 15 minute 12″ remix can be found over here. A bit different to his dear brother’s 3-buttons-undone appearance on Matty Johns last night.

    Anyhow I’ll still be heading along to all the Storm games I can get to this year (I’m a rotating shift worker you see) and going bananas for the team. I’d love to see the new stadium opened with the ceremonial tarring and feathering of Brian Waldron, and then having him launched into the Yarra by means of a large catapault. I think we could even get some AFL fans in to watch that.

    Finally I really really hope Ryan Hoffman wasn’t caught up in all this shyte as he’s my favouritest of favourite players because he slogs his guts out every week and doesn’t get all the exposure the superstars do but makes such a difference to the team.

    Thankyou and goodnight.

    I wonda how bitchy Cooper Cronk is feeling this morning?
    I wouldn’t want to be his cat.

  • Kiki

    SO MANY COMMENTS. I LOVE YOU GUYS SO MUCH.

    after all the adrenalin wore off, today i felt very very sad and down. i couldnt sleep last nite thinking about the whole thing.

    i went to the dentist today and he is this awesome Iranian dude and he asked me to explain the whole drama coz he didnt get it…and people…i shit you not…I CRIED. IN FRONT OF MY DENTIST.

    while in the waiting room i had been reading the Herald and was just so overwhelmed by all the drama and how far reaching it is and how this betrayal affects everyone in league and it got the better of me. i am so lame.

  • Kiki

    by the way, theres a silver lining in this whole thing and that is that it’s brought so many new commenters out of the woodwork. this is awesome and pls make sure u comment more often, we love you!!!!

  • Hazy

    It just upsets me that now people are saying some people/clubs up north play their players outside the cap by putting them on a certain poker machine and putting their extra payments through it.

    That breaks my heart, what we did was wrong but if this is happening then everyone should be made to pay.

    I do think we’re being made an example of but unless people come out and blow the whistle on these other teams it’s just going to continue… We need to fix the cap so ALL players are paid a good amount and NO team has to do any of this fuckery and pretty much stab fans in the heart.

    NRL cap is 4.1 million, yes? the AFL is 7.4 or something …. So not fair for any NRL player who we all know work harder and are generally just better than AFL players :(

  • Kiki

    well Hazy the issue with the cap is, people keep saying we should raise it, but there just ISN’T the amount of money available to have one like the AFL. effectively we are only a 2 state game, the AFL is pretty much nationwide apart from the Northern Territory. that means bigger crowds, memberships, merchandise etc etc….which adds up to more money in the game.

    every time people bring up the salary cap argument i always ask WHERE IS THIS MONEY COMING FROM. clubs already struggle to break even, let alone make a profit. they aren’t rolling in cash that they are keeping from the players.

    although obvs i agree that our players are better than fumbleball players.

  • sassy

    amen they deserve better than AFL players haze! but yeah the biggest question is where does the money come from? I agree with the idea of a salary cap, so you have to then find a way to make the cap larger.

    and it’s hard because australia’s a small market and league only really covers two states, so the ultimate answer is if clubs want to pay their players more, they and the NRL as a whole need to Make More Money and manage it better.

    if the AFL can spend more per player, it’s cause they’re better managed, more business-oriented and make more money.

  • baz

    the salary cap is there to create an even playing field across the teams right? so make it that – each team nominates their 26 man playing roster at the start of the season. pay those 26 players a base salary – the same for everyone. that gives the player an income should they be injured. then pay the 17 who line up each week a match payment – this is an incentive for the player to work and train harder to ensure they make the team and get that payment. if all the players are earning the same – clubs cant entice players with money that may push other players out and players will stay at a club for loyalty because thats where they want to play – not because someones paying them more.

    on top of that if a player still wants to earn more – let him go out and find his own sponsorship deals with sponsors not already directly associated to the club – that way if he leaves – he can take his sponsorship deal with him. it might also be a way of tricking the players into behaving – a sponsor is not gonna want someone representing them with a reputation for bad behaviour or causing scandals.

  • Elise/Miss Cronk

    Oh man, the day i turned on channel nine news and heard this my heart broke. I’ve been a storm supporter for 5 years, and all those years we’ve been cheating, and every single good thing i went to in those 5 years (3 Grandfinals in sydney, accommodation and flights paid for by me) have been stripped from me. But ill never forget the memories and the amazing feelings i received from our wins. I have 2007 and 2009 memoribilla, that would be worth quite a lot now :P

    I hope all the other cheating teams get court, and get a penalty as shit as this. I want them all to feel as I do, so then they can all stop having a go at me for supporting a ‘cheating’ team, and to go to games which mean nothing. Then everyone will understand the about of love i have, and wont spit at me when I turn up to support my team.

    If i find out the storm threesome (brett finch, ferocious bitch- cooper cronk and billy slater) knew about the salary cap cheating, pretty sure my heart would shrink, and id turn into the grinch that hated NRL.

    But i dont mind about GI. he can go leave. As long as those three and cammy, and new crush matthew duffie survive, ill be happy :)